The Supreme Court of India set aside the land acquisition proceedings for mining by M/s Dalmia Cements Bharat Limited in Scheduled Areas of Sundergarh District, Odisha, holding that the acquisition was governed by Section 2(2)(b) of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 (2013 Act). Reversing the High Court of Orissa, the Court ruled that mandatory requirements—including prior consent of at least 80% of affected families along with the Social Impact Assessment (SIA) process, mandatory Gram Sabha prior consent under Section 41(3) in Fifth Schedule areas, and an independent Expert Group under Section 7(1)—were breached.
Background and Procedural History
- M/s Dalmia Cements Bharat Limited held a mining lease (extended up to 29.02.2040, modified to 873.057 Ha) and submitted Form A proposals on 09.12.2015 under Section 2(1) of the 2013 Act to acquire surface rights over land in Kukuda, Bihabandha, and Lanjiberna villages in Sundergarh District, Odisha (a Fifth Schedule area).
- Administrative approval was granted on 23.08.2017 subject to Section 2(2)(b)(i) consent provisions, and after initial SIA notification and Gram Panchayat resolutions on 26.01.2020 rejecting the proposal, a fresh notification under Section 4(1) was issued on 24.02.2020.
- Following a public hearing scheduled for 16.04.2021 (disputed amid COVID-19 and RTI responses), SIA report submission (01.06.2021), Expert Group evaluation (08.06.2021), Section 8(2) declaration (22.06.2021), Section 11 notifications (06.07.2021), rejection of objections (22.10.2021), and Section 19 notification (03.11.2021), acquisition proceedings progressed.
- By judgment dated 06.09.2024 in Writ Petition (C) No. 31638/2022, the High Court of Orissa dismissed the appellants’ challenge on grounds including locus standi, non-applicability of Section 2(2)(b), continuing/subsequent consent, directory reading of Section 41 Gram Sabha consent, and inclusive Expert Group composition under Section 7(2). The appellants appealed to the Supreme Court.
Key Issues
- Whether the acquisition for mining by a private company was governed by Section 2(1) or Section 2(2)(b) of the 2013 Act, and whether prior consent of at least 80% of affected families was required before examination under Section 8.
- Whether prior Gram Sabha consent under Section 41(3) of the 2013 Act in a Scheduled Area is mandatory, and whether the Expert Group composition violated Section 7(1).
- How the 2013 Act interacts with the Mines and Minerals (Development & Regulation) Act, 1957 (MMDR Act), and whether the appellants had locus standi.
Legal Analysis and Ruling
- Applicability of Section 2(2)(b) and Prior Consent: Because the acquisition was at the instance of and for mining by a private company rather than for the State’s own use, hold, and control, Section 2(2)(b) applied. Prior consent of at least 80% of affected families in the prescribed manner (Form J under Rule 21 of the Odisha Rules) had to be obtained alongside the SIA process and ascertained before government examination under Section 8—treating consent as a continuing/post-facto process defeats the statute.
- Mandatory Gram Sabha Consent Under Section 41(3): In Fifth Schedule areas, Section 41(3) mandates prior Gram Sabha consent (“shall be obtained, in all cases”) before issuing a notification, distinct from the guiding phrases in Section 41(1) and (2). Both Gram Sabhas had rejected the proposal on 26.01.2020, and constitutional judicial review applies despite absence of an express statutory penalty in Section 41(3).
- Independence of Expert Group Under Section 7(1): Including a person connected to the requiring company (as Advisor, Land Acquisition) compromised the statutory mandate of an “independent multi-disciplinary Expert Group” under Section 7(1).
- 2013 Act and MMDR Act & Locus Standi: The 2013 Act and MMDR Act operate in distinct spheres without conflict, and once acquisition proceedings were initiated under the 2013 Act, they had to comply with it. The State could not defeat locus standi on technical/record-updating defaults or a curable affidavit defect.
Disposition
- The Supreme Court allowed the writ petition and appeal, set aside the impugned High Court judgment and the acquisition proceedings/notifications, granted liberty to initiate fresh acquisition proceedings in accordance with law and the judgment, and disposed of pending applications.



