The Supreme Court of India upheld the High Court of Delhi’s determination of mesne profits at Rs. 7/- per sq. ft. per month for the ground floor and Rs. 5/- per sq. ft. per month for the mezzanine floor, along with 7.5% simple interest (reducible to 6% on timely payment), for wrongful occupation of premises at Ansari Road, Daryaganj, New Delhi after termination of tenancy. Dismissing the appeals, the Court found no legal infirmity or perversity in the High Court’s balanced evidentiary assessment and brought finality to a three-decade-old dispute.
Background and Procedural History
- The appellants’ predecessors instituted a suit in 1990 for recovery of possession of premises at 1, Ansari Road, Daryaganj, New Delhi after terminating respondent no. 1’s tenancy from midnight of 31.12.1989, claiming damages for use and occupation at Rs. 1,47,500/- per month from 02.01.1990 with 15% interest.
- By judgment and decree dated 22.12.1998, the Trial Court decreed possession and ordered a preliminary inquiry under Order XX Rule 12 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC) for mesne profits; the decree for possession attained finality upon dismissal of SLP (C) No. 3879 of 2001 on 19.03.2001.
- In the Order XX Rule 12 CPC inquiry, the Trial Court on 30.04.2004 fixed mesne profits at Rs. 22/- per sq. ft. per month (ground floor carpet area) and Rs. 11/- per sq. ft. per month (mezzanine floor carpet area) with 15% interest.
- On 12.07.2010, the First Appellate Court set aside the Trial Court’s figures as speculative—noting differences between the old godown premises and the 1972 banking premises let to Vijaya Bank—and proceeded on the admitted rate of rent.
- In RSA Nos. 186 and 187 of 2010, by judgment dated 11.08.2011, the High Court of Delhi held that the First Appellate Court overlooked respondent no. 1’s witness (DW-1) admission of prevailing local rent of Rs. 5/- to Rs. 8/- per sq. ft. per month, raising a substantial question of law under Section 100 CPC, and fixed mesne profits at Rs. 7/- (ground floor) and Rs. 5/- (mezzanine floor) with 7.5% simple interest (or 6% if paid within two months). The appellants appealed to the Supreme Court seeking higher mesne profits and 15% interest.
Key Issue
- Whether the High Court erred in fixing mesne profits at Rs. 7/- and Rs. 5/- per sq. ft. per month and awarding 7.5% simple interest (with a 6% concession) upon finding that the First Appellate Court omitted material evidence regarding prevailing rental value.
Legal Analysis and Ruling
- Compensatory Nature and Evidentiary Estimation: Citing Martin and Harris Private Limited v. Rajendra Mehta, the Court observed that mesne profits compensate the owner for wrongful occupation through a fair, reasonable estimate based on property nature, location, prevailing rental value, evidence, and attendant circumstances, without a rigid formula or routine appellate interference absent arbitrariness or legal error.
- Omission of Material Admission Under Section 100 CPC: DW-1’s admission in chief examination that prevailing local rent at tenancy termination ranged between Rs. 5/- and Rs. 8/- per sq. ft. per month had a direct bearing on mesne profits, and overlooking it properly warranted correction under Section 100 CPC.
- Balanced Rate, Interest, and Finality: The High Court’s rates fell within the evidentiary range shown by DW-1 without mechanically adopting the lowest figure or equating the premises with Vijaya Bank’s premises. Following Mahant Naryana Dasjee Varu v. Board of Trustees, Tirumalai Tirupathi Devasthanam, interest is an integral part of mesne profits, and the High Court’s interest rates and finality after over three decades of litigation were fair and reasonable.
Disposition
- The Supreme Court found no ground to interfere and dismissed the appeals.



