Indian Judgements

Indian Judgements

Overhauling the Two-Child Norm: SC Re-evaluates Electoral Disqualifications

In this milestone judgment, a Two-Judge Bench of the Supreme Court of India stayed the disqualification of a Sarpanch under Section 14(1)(j-1) of the Maharashtra Village Panchayats Act, 1959 for having a third child. Recognizing that the underlying justification for population control laws has collapsed, the Supreme Court referred the landmark 2003 precedent Javed v. State of Haryana—which upheld two-child disqualification laws—to a larger Bench for immediate reconsideration.

The Court highlighted that over the past two decades, India’s Total Fertility Rate (TFR) has dropped from 3.0 to 1.9 (falling below the replacement rate of 2.1), exposing India to an impending demographic shift toward an aging population rather than a “population explosion”. Applying the doctrine of temporal reasonableness (cessante ratione cessat ipsa lex), the Court ruled that laws that penalize bearing more than two children have lost their constitutional and social rationale. Furthermore, the Court noted that such laws disproportionately disenfranchise socio-economically marginalized citizens and women, while severely infringing upon the right to reproductive autonomy guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution.

1. Factual Matrix & The Primary Question

  • Background: The appellant was elected Sarpanch of Kakoda Gram Panchayat in 2022. Her election was challenged and set aside under Section 14(1)(j-1) of the Maharashtra Village Panchayats Act, 1959 because she had given birth to her third child in 2014.
  • Issue Before the Court: While the lower authorities simply applied existing statutory provisions and the binding precedent in Javed v. State of Haryana (2003), the Supreme Court examined whether laws penalizing citizens with more than two children remain constitutionally sustainable when the underlying factual and demographic premises have fundamentally changed.

2. The Shifting Demographic Reality (2003 vs. 2026)

  • Collapse of the “Population Explosion” Premise: In Javed (2003), the Court relied on concerns over population explosion hindering socio-economic progress. At that time, India’s TFR was 3.0.
  • Current Demographic Metrics:
    • According to the Registrar General’s Sample Registration System (SRS) and NFHS-6 data, India’s TFR dropped to 1.9 as of 2024, falling below the replacement level of 2.1.
    • Annual population growth fell to 0.887% in 2025 (down from ~1.6% in 2005).
  • The Aging Population Risk: The decline in fertility combined with rising life expectancy means India will soon face an aging demographic structure. Projections indicate that the elderly (60+) population share will reach 15% by 2036 and ~20.8% by 2050, straining public finances and labor force participation.
  • Lessons from International Experiences: The Court pointed to China (which abandoned its one-child policy in 2015 and expanded to three children in 2021 due to rapid population aging) and Japan as warnings against treating fertility reduction as a policy achievement that can be easily reversed.

3. Role of Constitutional Courts & Temporal Reasonableness

  • Doctrine of Temporal Reasonableness: Citing Satyawati Sharma v. Union of India (2008), Malpe Vishwanath Acharya v. State of Maharashtra (1998), and State of Maharashtra v. Super Max International (2009), the Court reaffirmed that a law reasonable at the time of enactment can become arbitrary and unconstitutional with the passage of time if its foundational rationale ceases to exist (cessante ratione cessat ipsa lex).
  • Adapting to Change: Failing to adapt the law to evolving societal realities produces injustice and constitutes an abuse of power. When the legislative branch fails to review outdated statutory restrictions, constitutional courts have a duty to re-examine their constitutional sustainability.

4. Re-evaluating the Socio-Political Assumptions in Javed

  • Exclusion of Marginalized Citizens from Representation: The Court criticized the selective imposition of two-child disqualifications strictly at the Panchayati Raj level, while no such restriction exists for State Assemblies or Parliament. Quoting Dr. B.R. Ambedkar and Dr. Rajendra Prasad, the Bench noted that the right to representation and to hold public office are core facets of citizenship that should not be constrained by top-down, elitist restrictions.
  • Disproportionate Impact on Women: The Court highlighted empirical studies demonstrating that two-child norms in a patriarchal framework severely disempower women. Due to strong son preference and lack of reproductive choice control, such laws have led to forced abortions, desertion of pregnant wives, and denial of paternity to evade disqualification.
  • Violation of Reproductive Autonomy (Article 21): Citing Suchita Srivastava v. Chandigarh Administration (2009) and S. Puttaswamy v. Union of India (2017), the Court held that the decision of whether and when to have children lies at the heart of individual privacy, personal liberty, and human dignity under Article 21. Forcing citizens to choose between reproductive autonomy and democratic participation is unconscionable.

5. Final Conclusions and Directions

  1. Reference to Larger Bench: The Supreme Court formally referred Javed v. State of Haryana (2003) to a larger Bench of the Supreme Court for full reconsideration.
  2. Interim Protection Maintained: The operation of the High Court’s order setting aside the appellant’s election was stayed, permitting her to continue serving as Sarpanch of Kakoda Gram Panchayat pending the outcome of the appeal.

2026 INSC 1193

Mangala Bhimrao Ingle v. The Additional Commissioner, Amravati Division & Ors. (D.O.J. 04.11.2026)

2026 INSC 1193 click here to view full text of judgment

Next Story

Grandson’s Birth Right in Father’s Partitioned Property

The Supreme Court of India held that property inherited by a Hindu male as a Class I heir under Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, and allotted to him in a partition among Class I heirs, becomes his exclusive individual property rather than joint family or coparcenary property vis-à-vis his own son. Consequently, a grandson born after the grandfather’s death has no birth right to seek partition of his living father’s share.

Background and Procedural History

  • The appellant, a minor represented by his mother and natural guardian, filed Original Suit No. 1698 of 1997 seeking partition and possession of a half share in 1,811 sq. ft. of land, pleading that it was joint family property of his grandfather, late N. Ramakrishnan, inherited along with his father (first defendant).
  • The first defendant’s sister, G. Lalitha, had filed partition suit C.S. No. 1728 of 1993 regarding N. Ramakrishnan’s property, resulting in a compromise decree dated 03.02.1994 under which the first defendant received 1,811 sq. ft. of land.
  • The appellant was born on 06.01.1994, after the 1993 suit was filed and before the 03.02.1994 compromise decree.
  • The first defendant executed sale deeds on 03.04.1997 and 17.04.1997 in favour of defendant nos. 2 and 3, who contested the suit claiming absolute ownership under the compromise decree and bona fide purchase. The appellant’s suit did not challenge the compromise decree or the sale deeds.
  • The Trial Court granted a preliminary decree for partition, which the First Appellate Court (High Court) set aside on 11.08.2010, holding that under Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, the first defendant took his share as an absolute owner and the appellant acquired no right by birth. The appellant appealed to the Supreme Court.

Key Issue

  • Whether the appellant could claim a half share and seek partition by birth in land allotted to his still-living father upon partition of property originally belonging to the appellant’s grandfather.

Legal Analysis and Ruling

  • Succession Under Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956: Following CWT v. Chander Sen, Yudhisthir v. Ashok Kumar, and Radha Bai v. Ram Narayan, the Court reiterated that under Section 8, a male Hindu’s property devolves upon Class I heirs to the exclusion of others. A living son’s son (grandson) is excluded from Class I heirs, and a son inheriting property under Section 8 takes it in his individual capacity rather than as karta of his own Hindu Undivided Family vis-à-vis his son.
  • Effect of Partition and Tenancy in Common: Upon N. Ramakrishnan’s death prior to the 1993 suit, Class I heirs succeeded as tenants in common rather than joint tenants, and the compromise decree dated 03.02.1994 allotted exclusive shares to the heirs, ending joint coparcenary character in the allotted share.
  • Inapplicability of Pre-2005 Section 6 and Tamil Nadu Amendment (Section 29-A): Unamended Section 6 and Section 29-A inserted by the Hindu Succession (Tamil Nadu Amendment) Act, 1989 did not apply on the facts, as succession had opened upon N. Ramakrishnan’s death before the appellant was born, and the appellant was not a surviving coparcener at his grandfather’s death. Once the property became the first respondent’s exclusive individual property after partition, the appellant could not claim coparcenary rights by birth during his father’s lifetime.

Disposition

  • The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal with no order as to costs and disposed of pending applications.

2026 INSC 1208

J. Rajesh (Minor) Thr. His Mother and Natural Guardian J. Gomathi v. M. Kumaran (Dead) Thr. LRs. & Ors. (D.O.J. 06.11.2026)

2026 INSC 1208 click here to view full text of judgment

Next Story

Balance Sheet Entries and Limitation in Civil Recovery Suits

The Supreme Court of India held that continuous reflection of unpaid dues in a defendant’s balance sheets can constitute a valid acknowledgment of liability under Section 18 of the Limitation Act, 1963, renewing limitation and preventing threshold rejection of a plaint under Order VII Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC). Setting aside the High Court’s order that had rejected the plaint as time-barred, the Court restored the recovery suit for trial while leaving all substantive merits open.

Background and Procedural History

  • The original plaintiff, Wazir Hussain, entered into a civil works contract dated 10.02.2000 with the respondent-society for construction work on a multi-story building in Mayur Vihar, Delhi, raising running bills between 2000 and 2003.
  • In 2014, he filed a suit under Order XXXVII CPC seeking recovery of Rs. 11,16,000/- along with Rs. 11,04,840/- interest (at 9% p.a.) and further interest until realization.
  • The defendant-society sought rejection of the plaint under Order VII Rule 11 CPC on grounds including limitation, absence of a cause of action, and non-maintainability over alleged embezzlement.
  • On 06.01.2020, the Trial Court dismissed the rejection application, holding that entries in the defendant’s balance sheets from 2004–2005 up to 2013 amounted to acknowledgment of debt starting fresh limitation periods, while leaving maintainability and bill genuineness for trial.
  • On 04.11.2024, the High Court of Delhi allowed the defendant’s revision petition and rejected the plaint as barred by limitation, finding that the bank statements did not establish acknowledgment beyond 2005 and noting that the plaintiff had not produced a balance sheet or other document showing acknowledgment. The plaintiff’s legal heir appealed to the Supreme Court.

Key Issue

  • Whether the suit could be rejected at the threshold as barred by limitation given the entries in the defendant’s balance sheets up to 2013.

Legal Analysis and Ruling

  • Acknowledgment Under Section 18 of the Limitation Act, 1963: Under Section 18(1), a signed written acknowledgment of liability made before the expiration of the prescribed limitation period starts a fresh period of limitation from the date of acknowledgment.
  • Precedent on Balance Sheets: Relying on Asset Reconstruction Company (India) Ltd. v. Bishal Jaiswal and Axis Bank Ltd. v. Naren Sheth, the Court noted that balance sheet entries can constitute an acknowledgment of liability under Section 18, subject to reading the entry within the context of the balance sheet as a whole, including accompanying notes or the auditor’s report.
  • Contextual Link to Plaintiff’s Claim: The 2004–2005 balance sheet and bank reconciliation statement expressly recorded three cheques issued to Wazir Hussain Contractor, connecting him to the records, and subsequent balance sheets continued carrying forward balances pertaining to 2004–2005 through 2013. Section 18 does not require naming the specific creditor or following a rigid format so long as the entry, read with surrounding circumstances, indicates a subsisting jural relationship.
  • Scope of Order VII Rule 11 CPC & No Condonation Needed: Whether the exact sum claimed was owed, and how cheques and carried-forward figures interrelate, are evidentiary matters for trial rather than grounds for conclusive determination at the Order VII Rule 11 stage. Because valid Section 18 acknowledgments automatically renewed limitation on each subsequent acknowledgment date, no condonation of delay application was required.

Disposition

  • The Supreme Court allowed the appeal, set aside the High Court’s order dated 04.11.2024, revived the suit before the Trial Court, and kept all questions on the merits open.

2026 INSC 1207

Yusuf v. Vigyapan Loke Delhi Advertising CGHS Ltd. (D.O.J. 06.11.2026)

2026 INSC 1207 click here to view full text of judgment

Next Story

Sanction Not Needed for Forgery and Fraudulent Acts

In this case, the appellant challenged the Bombay High Court’s order which had quashed criminal proceedings against Respondent No. 1 (a City Survey Officer) under Section 482 of the Cr.P.C. The High Court had quashed the chargesheets on the ground that prior sanction under Section 197 of the Cr.P.C., read with the Maharashtra Amendment to Section 156(3) of the Cr.P.C., was mandatory for prosecuting a public servant and that the application for sanction was not made to the competent authority. The Supreme Court allowed the appeals, setting aside the High Court’s order, and held that acts involving the fabrication of records, forgery, and criminal conspiracy to illegally alter mutation entries and transfer property do not fall within the discharge or purported discharge of official duties. Consequently, prior sanction under Section 197 or the Maharashtra Amendment is not attracted, and the criminal proceedings before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Dhule, were ordered to be restored.

  • Background of the Dispute: The appellant, acting for charitable and cooperative housing bodies, alleged that Respondent No. 1 in collusion with others manipulated records and approved an illegal mutation entry (Mutation Entry No. 7062) based on a tampered and incomplete application, effectively removing the property ownership of the trust and society.
  • High Court’s Quashing Order: The High Court quashed the FIRs and resulting chargesheets (RCC Nos. 1020 of 2023 and 119 of 2024) pending before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Dhule, holding that prior sanction under Section 197 and the Maharashtra Amendment to Section 156(3) of the Cr.P.C. was required and had not been validly obtained from the competent authority.
  • Legal Test for Official Duty: Citing established precedents, the Supreme Court reiterated that protection under Section 197 of the Cr.P.C. applies only when the act complained of bears a reasonable nexus or direct link with the discharge of public duties. Acts involving criminal conspiracy, forgery, fabrication of documents, and fraud cannot form part of a public servant’s official duties.
  • Supreme Court’s Ruling: The Supreme Court concluded that the allegations against Respondent No. 1 involve fabricating documents and manipulating property records to cheat and illegally transfer land, which completely lie outside the scope of official duties. Therefore, the requirement of prior sanction does not arise.
  • Final Directions: The impugned order of the Bombay High Court was set aside, the appeals were allowed, and RCC Nos. 1020 of 2023 and 119 of 2024 were restored to the file of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Dhule, to proceed in accordance with law.

2026 INSC 1235

Ashok v. Mahesh & Anr. (D.O.J. 17.11.2026)

2026 INSC 1235 click here to view full text of judgment

Next Story

Upholding Arbitral Autonomy and Restricting Judicial Interference

In this case, the Rajasthan Rajya Vidyut Utpadan Nigam Ltd. (RVUNL) filed a Special Leave Petition under Article 136 of the Constitution to challenge a judgment of the Rajasthan High Court rendered under Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. The High Court had reversed a Commercial Court order that had set aside an Arbitral Tribunal’s award and additional award in favor of Parsa Kente Collieries Limited (PKCL). The underlying dispute arose from claims regarding coal mining and delivery operations under a Coal Mining and Delivery Agreement (CMDA) following the cancellation and reallocation of the PEKB coal block. The Supreme Court examined the limited parameters of judicial review under Sections 34 and 37 of the Act as well as the discretionary scope under Article 136. The Court held that the Commercial Court had exceeded its jurisdiction by reappraising evidence and substituting its own plausible views for those of the Arbitral Tribunal, and that the High Court had correctly restored the arbitral awards. Consequently, the Supreme Court dismissed the Special Leave Petition, reinforcing the principle of minimal judicial intervention in arbitral matters.

  • Background and Arbitral Proceedings: PKCL initiated arbitration against RVUNL concerning nine distinct claims arising from the operation and reallocation of the PEKB coal block. The Sole Arbitrator passed an Award on January 15, 2021, allowing several claims in full or part, and subsequently passed an Additional Award on July 5, 2021, allowing a claim for land acquisition costs.
  • Commercial Court’s Interference: Under Section 34 of the Act, the Commercial Court upheld findings on certain claims but set aside findings on multiple other claims (including stamp duty, legal fees, project-affected families, and the vocational training centre), and set aside the Additional Award on limitation grounds. Finding it lacked modification powers, it set aside both awards in their entirety.
  • High Court’s Appellate Ruling: On appeal under Section 37, the Rajasthan High Court held that the Commercial Court exceeded its jurisdiction by treating the proceedings like a regular appeal and reappraising evidence, thereby restoring both the main Award and the Additional Award.
  • Scope of Judicial Review under Sections 34 and 37: The Supreme Court reiterated that courts exercising powers under Sections 34 and 37 must not act as regular appellate courts. An arbitral award cannot be set aside merely because an alternative view is possible or because of an erroneous application of law, unless it suffers from patent illegality or perversity.
  • Evaluation of Claims: The Supreme Court conducted a claim-by-claim scrutiny and found that the Arbitral Tribunal’s interpretations of the CMDA and Supplementary Agreement were plausible, well-reasoned, and free from patent illegality. It held that the Commercial Court erred in interfering with the tribunal’s findings, and that the High Court’s restoration of the awards was legally sound.
  • Final Order: The Supreme Court dismissed the Special Leave Petition, emphasizing respect for the autonomy, finality, and minimal judicial interference intended under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.

2026 INSC 1234

Rajasthan Rajya Vidyut Utpadan Nigam Ltd. v. Parsa Kente Collieries Limited (D.O.J. 16.11.2026)

2026 INSC 1234 click here to view full text of judgment

Hi Judgments Online