This civil appeal challenged the judgment of the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT), which had set aside an NCLT order and restored a Section 9 Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC) petition filed by the State Trading Corporation of India (STC) against M/s. Ganesh Benzoplast Ltd. The Supreme Court examined whether an unsecured creditor or a contingent liability holder can bypass a sanctioned rehabilitation scheme under the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985 (SICA) to claim full dues via IBC proceedings. The Apex Court held that once a rehabilitation scheme is approved, its provisions—including the scaling down of unsecured liabilities—are binding on all creditors, and contingent liabilities can only mature up to the scaled-down framework. Finding that the appellant company had already paid the maximum recoverable amount of 25% of its principal dues as quantified by the NCLT, the Supreme Court allowed the appeal, set aside the NCLAT judgment, and restored the original NCLT order disposing of the company petition.
- Background and Facts:
- The appellant company, engaged in chemical manufacturing and petroleum storage terminals, faced severe financial distress and was declared a sick industrial unit by the BIFR under SICA in May 2010.
- A Draft Rehabilitation Scheme (DRS) was formulated, and a final Rehabilitation Scheme (RS) was approved by the Delhi High Court on December 4, 2015.
- Under Clause 11.11 of the approved RS, unsecured creditors were to be paid 25% of their principal dues in five equal annual instalments.
- The respondent (STC) was not listed among the 191 unsecured creditors in Annexure-V, but was instead categorized at Serial No. 6 under Annexure VI(a) as a “contingent liability” amounting to ₹35 crores. STC never challenged this categorization or the published DRS.
- Initiation of IBC Proceedings:
- Despite the binding rehabilitation framework, STC issued a demand notice under Section 8 of the IBC on March 20, 2018, claiming ₹26 crores across export, domestic, and ‘C’ Form default categories, and subsequently filed a Section 9 petition before the NCLT.
- During the NCLT proceedings, the appellant submitted the required ‘C’ Forms on January 30, 2020, and offered to settle the principal dues in line with the RS.
- On February 13, 2020, the NCLT disposed of the company petition by directing the appellant to pay ₹2,18,88,421/—representing 25% of the principal dues—within a stipulated timeframe, which the appellant paid and STC accepted without prejudice.
- Appellate History:
- STC appealed to the NCLAT, which ultimately allowed the appeal via judgment on January 21, 2026, restoring the company petition to the NCLT for fresh consideration under the premise that STC could not be forced into accepting only 25% under an unfulfilled payment timeline.
- The appellant company then appealed to the Supreme Court, which had stayed the NCLAT judgment on March 17, 2026.
- Supreme Court’s Reasoning and Legal Principles:
- Binding Nature of SICA Rehabilitation Schemes: Citing precedents such as Modi Rubber Limited v. Continental Carbon India Limited and Fertilizer Corporation of India Limited v. Coromandel Sacks Private Limited, the Supreme Court reaffirmed that an approved rehabilitation scheme binds all creditors (including unsecured creditors and minority claimants). Permitting creditors to opt out or reject scaled-down values would render schemes unworkable and frustrate SICA’s revival objectives.
- Status of Contingent Liabilities: Since STC remained categorized as a “contingent liability” and never sought legal crystallization of its dues prior to issuing an IBC notice, it could at best attain the status of an unsecured creditor entitled strictly to the 25% scaled-down principal payout under Clause 11.11.
- Inapplicability of IBC for Liability Quantification: The IBC regime is not designed for the initial determination or quantification of unadjudicated liabilities of a sick company undergoing rehabilitation.
- Final Relief Granted:
- The Supreme Court held that the NCLAT erred in reopening the matter because nothing left to be adjudicated once the maximum permissible amount under the RS (₹2,18,88,421/-) had already been paid pursuant to the NCLT’s initial order.
- The appeal was allowed, setting aside the NCLAT’s January 21, 2026 judgment and restoring the NCLT’s February 13, 2020 disposal order, with parties bearing their own costs.




