This appeal arose from a judgment passed by the High Court of Bombay (Nagpur Bench), which had upheld the termination of an Assistant Teacher by a school management committee. The appellant challenged her termination on the ground that the departmental inquiry was vitiated by severe institutional and personal bias, owing to a “total familial capture” of the management and the inquiry apparatus. The Supreme Court examined whether overlapping roles (with the Secretary acting as complainant, witness, and prosecutor, and his real brother serving as the Convenor of the Inquiry Committee) gave rise to a reasonable likelihood of bias. Holding that the rules of natural justice were fundamentally breached and that the doctrine of necessity did not apply, the Supreme Court set aside the High Court’s judgment, restored the School Tribunal’s order of reinstatement with back wages, and directed authorities to consider absorbing the teacher in another hundred per cent grant-in-aid school.
- Factual Background: The appellant was appointed as an Assistant Teacher in 2009, with her appointment approved in 2015. After the school received a 20% grant-in-aid status, her name was allegedly excluded from salary grant bills by the Secretary (Rajesh Masurkar), prompting her to lodge complaints with the Education Department. Subsequently, the management initiated departmental disciplinary proceedings against her, leading to her termination in February 2022.
- Proceedings Below: The School Tribunal initially quashed the termination and ordered reinstatement with full back wages. Upon remand by the High Court, the Tribunal reaffirmed its order, noting that the inquiry was a farce and that the Secretary could not act as a judge in his own cause. However, the High Court allowed the management’s writ petition and upheld the termination, concluding that the inquiry followed due process.
- Core Issue on Bias: The Supreme Court considered whether the circumstances gave rise to a reasonable likelihood of bias from the perspective of a fair-minded person. The Court observed that the Executive Committee was dominated by a single family (the Masurkars). Specifically, Rajesh Masurkar acted simultaneously as the employer’s secretary, the CEO who issued the charge-sheet, a principal witness on multiple charges, and the person who signed the termination order, while his real brother (Prakash Masurkar) served as the Convenor (“Judge”) of the Inquiry Committee.
- Legal Principles Invocations:
- The Court reaffirmed that the test for bias is not actual proof of partiality, but a “reasonable likelihood of bias” or “real possibility of bias” from the standpoint of a fair-minded observer.
- The maxim Nemo Judex in Causa Sua (no one should be a judge in their own cause) is a constitutional imperative under Article 14. Its breach is a foundational jurisdictional defect that cannot be cured by mere compliance with procedural formalities.
- Close kinship disqualifies a person from adjudicating where it creates a reasonable apprehension of bias, and administrative tribunals are held to the same rigorous standards as courts.
- The Doctrine of Necessity did not apply because other unrelated members of the Executive Committee were available to serve as the Convenor.
- Relief Granted: The Supreme Court allowed the appeal, set aside the High Court’s judgment, and restored the School Tribunal’s order quashing the termination. Additionally, it directed the Education Officer to explore absorbing the appellant into another 100% grant-in-aid school under relevant service rules.
2026 INSC 1229
Ku. Kiran D/O Purushottam Bhujade v. Sudhir Shikshan Sanstha & Ors. (D.O.J. 17.11.2026)



