The present civil appeals arose from judgments of the High Court of Chhattisgarh, which had affirmed orders declining to interfere with the compulsory retirement of the appellants (who were working as Assistant Grade-III in the Legal Metrology Department). Pursuant to a government circular dated 25th April 2017 directing the review of service records for employees who had attained 50 years of age or completed 20 years of qualifying service, a Screening Committee reviewed the records of eligible employees. Based on uniform criteria—including integrity assessments, overall service records falling below the benchmark of Grade ‘B’, and consistent ‘C’ gradings reflecting declining performance between 2013 and 2017—the Committee recommended the compulsory retirement of the appellants in the public interest. The Supreme Court dismissed the appeals, holding that an order of compulsory retirement is neither punitive nor stigmatic, uncommunicated adverse entries can be considered for such reviews, and subsequent promotions or regularizations do not efface subsequent adverse performance.
- Scope of Judicial Review: An order of compulsory retirement is based on the subjective satisfaction of the competent authority regarding public interest and “dead wood,” and judicial review is restricted to examining whether valid, relevant material existed and whether prescribed criteria were followed.
- Uniformity and Negative Equality: The Court held that the screening parameters were applied uniformly to all eligible employees, and an employee cannot challenge compulsory retirement merely because another similarly situated person was not penalized, as the doctrine of negative equality does not apply under Article 14.
- Relevance of Post-Promotion Entries: The principle that adverse entries lose significance upon promotion applies only to pre-promotion entries; entries recorded after promotion relating to performance in the promoted post remain fully relevant.
- Uncommunicated Adverse Remarks: Uncommunicated adverse entries and below-benchmark gradings can legitimately be taken into account for compulsory retirement, distinguishing the rule from cases involving career promotions (Dev Dutt and Sukhdev Singh).
- Non-Stigmatic Nature: Internal deliberations and minutes of the Screening Committee do not impart a stigmatic character to the consequential order, which was a pure administrative review and not a disciplinary proceeding.
2026 INSC 1205
Chatur Singh Dhruv v. The State of Chhattisgarh & Ors. (D.O.J. 06.11.2026)



