The Delhi Development Authority (DDA) challenged a common judgment of the Delhi High Court Division Bench that dismissed the DDA’s writ petitions and affirmed the Central Administrative Tribunal’s orders directing the release of the respondents’ gratuity along with interest. The respondents, who had retired after serving for decades, were prosecuted under corruption charges but were completely acquitted by the Trial Court in 2017, although the State’s criminal leave petition against the acquittal remained pending. The Supreme Court dismissed the DDA’s appeals, holding that the Trial Court’s acquittal continues to hold the field and that withholding terminal dues indefinitely during a protracted appellate stage would render pensionary benefits illusory. The Court upheld the conditional release of gratuity backed by an undertaking to refund the amount if the appeal ultimately succeeds, as an equitable balance safeguarding public funds and retired employees’ rights.
- Factual Background & Prosecution:
- The respondents (Rajender Kumar Sharma and Satendra Pal) joined DDA service in 1984.
- In May 2001, an FIR was registered by the Anti-Corruption Branch (ACB) alleging that DDA, MCD, and slum department officials had conspired with property dealers to include fictitious dwellers in a joint survey for wrongful gain.
- Following prosecution sanction, a criminal case was tried, and the Special Judge acquitted the respondents on February 28, 2017, while convicting some co-accused.
- The State subsequently filed a Criminal Leave Petition challenging the acquittal in 2017, where notice was issued by the High Court without any stay operating against the trial court’s judgment.
- Withholding of Terminal Dues & Litigation History:
- Both respondents superannuated in December 2018 and September 2021 respectively.
- Citing Rule 69(1)(c) of the Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1972, the DDA withheld their gratuity (amounting to ₹18,52,224 and ₹15,43,113) due to the pending appeal.
- The Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT) directed the release of gratuity with interest, subject to an undertaking by the respondents to refund the amounts if the judicial proceedings eventually concluded against them, relying on precedent involving co-accused (Kishan Lal Taneja v. GNCTD).
- The Delhi High Court dismissed DDA’s writ petitions and affirmed the Tribunal’s directions, leading to the present appeals before the Supreme Court.
- Supreme Court’s Reasoning and Findings:
- Precedent and Consistency: The Court noted that relief had already been extended to multiple similarly placed co-accused who were acquitted under the same judgment (such as in Kishan Lal Taneja, Rajinder Khurana, and Laxmi Narain), and rejected the DDA’s contention that these decisions were per incuriam.
- Effect of Acquittal: The acquittal by the Trial Court holds the field until overturned on appeal. The mere pendency of an appeal under Section 378 of the CrPC since 2017—with no stay operating—cannot justify withholding retirement dues earned over decades.
- Misplaced Reliance on Case Law: The DDA’s reliance on Bikram Chand Rana v. Himachal Pradesh Road Transport Corporation was misplaced because that case dealt with an employee whose departmental proceedings concluded while a trial remained pending, whereas here the trial had concluded with an acquittal.
- Balancing Equities: Requiring superannuated employees of advanced age to await uncertain appellate outcomes without terminal dues would render their benefits illusory. The condition requiring an undertaking to refund the money adequately protects the DDA’s financial interests while honoring the employees’ rights.




